The other version is nothing more than a rumor that got twisted and pulled into a monstrosity that fans somehow transformed into true facts.
Batista and Melina developed a short-term relationship and in Batista's biography, he states that they only started dating after the divorce from his wife.
The relationship didn't last long thus Melina and Morrison worked out their differences and continued back to being a couple.
Rumor In this version, Melina and Morrison never broke up, but Morrison allowed or "loaned" Melina to Batista while Batista was still married to his wife (Pro Wrestling Torch, h/t Ringside News).
The world is a very cruel and unfair environment that is riddled with double standards, lies and hypocrites.
Rumors spread faster than the weeds that grow in the cracks of every sidewalk we walk upon on a daily basis.
Within the wrestling world, fans are the perfect examples of leading the charge of double standards when it comes to their favorite wrestlers and Divas they cheer for relentlessly.
Fans moan and groan over the fact that WWE Divas do not get the respect they deserve, and they all yearn for the Divas to have more in-ring time.
Of course, these same so-called fans make their routine bathroom breaks during Divas matches and routinely say they suck.
They wish for the Divas to have the same respect as their male counterparts, yet they have shown that they do not hold the Divas in that regard. Despite tremendous skills between the ropes and an ability to cut a decent promo, she is bashed left and right by wrestling fans all over to the point where they disregard her achievements and speak ill of her to no end.
The Morrison fans celebrated on the streets when the news broke that she was future endeavored.
In my mind, there really two versions of this so-called Morrison/Melina/Batista "controversy." One version is the truth where it's nothing more than a break-up leading to a fling, then ending in the original couples getting back together.